Whether seen as a problem or not, the prevalence of gambling in today’s society would be difficult to deny. Digital offerings, such as online casinos, sports betting apps and prediction markets, backed by massive marketing budgets have made gambling more accessible to the average person. From observing individuals who engage with these digital platforms, I have noticed two specific misconceptions people lean on when attempting to rationalise their behaviour.
First, some say that the mere fact that we live in an uncertain world makes gambling rational. This is simply a fallacy. Gambling in an uncertain world can be rational but is not necessarily so. To reason through this, I begin with definitions. I define betting as any action one takes to increase the degree to which they are affected by the outcome of a random event and define hedging as the direct opposite – action taken to reduce exposure. A person living in an uncertain world is in effect forced to make bets. Take the instance of Joe who would like to do some shopping at the nearby supermarket. By deciding to go to the supermarket, he is effectively making a bet on whether it will rain or not. If Joe is risk averse and believes that there is a sufficiently high chance of rain, he may hedge his bet by bringing an umbrella along with him. If he believes, however, that the chance it rains is sufficiently low, he may decide to make the trip without an umbrella. But if he is risk loving, he makes the trip without the umbrella even if he believes that he is taking an unfair bet (i.e., the chance it rains is high enough that a risk-neutral individual would bring along an umbrella).
Similarly, John, who is a die-hard fan of the ABC sports team, takes effective bets on the team’s games. He is always happy when they win and unhappy when they lose. John can hedge his exposure to the team’s results by making a small bet against them. Now whenever the team wins, he is happy about the victory but unhappy about the money lost and whenever the team loses, the reverse is the case. Betting on the games to increase his overall exposure to the results as opposed to reducing it is only rational behaviour if he is risk loving.
The second misconception revolves around the belief that the popular practice of investing in the stock market is itself a form of gambling. Some people reason that there is essentially no difference between gambling on betting apps and prediction markets and investing in the stock market so they should not be criticised for their choice of medium. This misconception stems from the misunderstanding of what makes the stock market a “good” bet. Over time, the value of stocks is largely driven by the productive capacity of the underlying businesses. We generally expect this productive capacity to increase over time which makes betting on the performance of the stock market a more than fair bet (at least in the long run). This stands in contrast to the gambling industry which offers almost exclusively unfair bets. It is important to note that these bets are unfair by design as they have to be unfair for the businesses to earn revenue from their operations.
Gambling businesses routinely weed out customers who are able to tilt the odds in their favour. Casinos watch out for people applying techniques like card counting to gain an advantage and sports betting sites ban skilled bettors who do extensive research to take advantage of mispriced bets. Prediction markets bring together market participants who take opposite sides of event contracts and collect transaction fees on the trading activity. Hence, they do not have to worry about market participants who gain an advantage through insider trading. This is because any excess profits earned by insider traders are earned at the expense of other market participants and not the company behind the market.
Earlier, I mentioned that taking unfair bets can be rational if the bettor is risk loving. It turns out though that a more than fair bet is preferable to an unfair one even for a risk-loving individual. Thus, passing up a bet which is more than fair bet for one which is unfair is generally not rational behaviour.
Written by: Ugonna Onyemere
Leave a Reply